- Parker, Anna — 1890 to 1974
- Parker, Isaac — Died 1961
- Paynesmith, Judy Wolff — 1946 to 2025
- Peel, John — 1940 to 2026
- Peranich, Gene John — 1943 to 2026
- Perry, Arliss — 1931 to 2025
- Pettigrew, Willis — c1820 to 1913
- Pollard, Thomas — c1806 to 1890
- Porter, Ethel — c1868 to 1904
- Puckett, Jean Francois —1962 to 2025
- Putman, Calvin — Died 1904